HRLB (High-Risk /Low-Benefit) Exercise of the Month

This section is meant to inform you of traditionally accepted exercises that don’t actually give you the benefits you seek, and may actually be causing more harm to your body than good. Performing exercises that are not HRLB will not only be more beneficial to your body in terms of results, but may also prevent injuries that could set you back months. In most cases, these exercises have been passed down in gyms, from generations of weightlifters who haven’t taken the time to analyze the movement in terms of biomechanics, safety, and effectiveness. It should be realized that weightlifting is no longer confined to young male bodybuilders looking only to get as big as possible, but now includes the elderly, female, and special populations as well. My job as a Fitness Professional is to promote safe and effective forms of exercise that have established guidelines and succeed in reaching the goals set out by the client. Also, I am sure that most of you who spend any amount of time working out would rather be doing exercises that give you results instead of injury for the time and effort you put in.

Upright Row

My belief is that this exercise has a high risk-to-benefit ratio and that there are safer alternatives to train the muscles supposedly being targeted. What is the goal of an upright row? If you were to ask some people, or even some personal trainers, they may say,”Traps, and Middle Delts, (shoulders), or maybe even External Rotators.” True enough, these muscles are being worked to some extent throughout the range of motion, but let’s take a look at what actually is going on. As you hold a barbell at shoulders’ width in front of the body and attempt to pull it to upward, the shoulder is typically forced to abduct, (move away from the midline of the body), and externally rotate from an excessive internally rotated position. This motion, combined with the position of the shoulder at the beginning of the movement not only allows for a limited available range of motion, and improper loading of the muscles you are hoping to target, but worse, it places an enormous amount of stress upon and inside the joint itself, most notably, the risk of impingement of the biceps tendon, supraspinatus, (the top rotator cuff muscle), and bursae, (fluid filled sacks that provide smooth gliding within the joint). Stress is also placed upon the wrists as they are forced to adjust or deviate out of natural positioning having to accommodate holding a straight bar. To make matters worse, the amount of resistance most exercisers use for this exercise is excessive only compounding the detrimental effects discussed and incorporating bad posture, momentum, and compensatory patterns. Although variations to this exercise may prevent some of these maladies, such as using dumbbells or a cable, using a cambered bar, changing grip width, altering shoulder blade, (scapular), position, or changing the range of motion may help, the inherit risks of this exercise are still present. Which brings us back to our goal in the first place. What muscles are we looking to target and work? If emphasizing the middle portion of the deltoid is your goal, why not choose the lateral raise, that is its’ primary job, abduction, (move the arm away from the side of the body). The Upper Trapezius? Why not perform its natural movement: Elevation, (shrugging). The External Rotators of the shoulder are best worked performing what they do best, external rotation from various degrees of abduction and directions of resistance using tubing or dumbbells. Correct application of the resistance is imperative and is beyond the scope of this current discussion. Although some may argue that this is a beneficial and safe exercise and is a natural motion dictated in everyday life and athletics, a closer look at the facts will tell you otherwise.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.